Menu

schmoo.pies

Baked fresh to order for you in two sizes - Whole Pie 9" and Just Enough 4.5". Whole Pie available with a Gluten Free crust for additional $3.

Original Schmoo Fudge Pie

$25/$10

What started it all. The gooey fudge pie doesn't last long once brought home. Wonderful as is (my preference) but don't doubt its amazing flavor with your favorite ice cream or whipped cream.

Peanut Butter Fudge Pie

$25/10

Our original recipe with the perfect amount of peanut butter to make anyone ready for seconds. Can't be beaten for those who love the fudge peanut butter combination. Available with Gluten Free peanut butter.

Specialty Schmoo.Pies

Baked with an extra special twist and available in both Whole and Just Enough sizes.

Key Lime Pie

$28

Enjoy a little taste of sunshine with our Key Lime Pie, our second most requested pie next to our Original Fudge. Only available for a limited amount of time and available in Gluten Free too!

Coconut Pie

$30

Our amazing Coconut Pie will have you ready for the islands. Available starting April 12th but pre-order yours today.

Heath Bar Pie

$28/$10

Our latest fun is taking our Original Fudge pie and baking in toffee pieces then topping it off with more toffee, caramel drizzle and sprinkled sea salt. Trust me, you won't want to share.

Chess Pie

$28

This classic pie is just the right amount of sweet with a touch of tart. Order this southern classic for your next supper club or simply for your weeknight pick-me-up.

Kentucky Bourbon Pecan

$28/$10

Inspired by the running of the horses, our Kentucky Bourbon Pecan is sure to be the winner for dessert. Using our Original Fudge, we combine pecans with a touch of bourbon to bring a smile to anyones face.

Schmoo S’Mores

$28/$10

Bring home the best part of camping with this amazing pie. It’s our Original Fudge on a graham cracker crust topped with toasted marshmallow fluff. Take a bite, close your eyes and you'll smell the campfire. Available in Gluten Free for additoinal $3.

Irish Whiskey

$28/$10

A huge hit during our St. Patrick’s Day special, we decided to make this one a fixed flavor. Combining our Original with just the right amount of whiskey, it will be your favorite too.

Monkey Business

$28/$10

Our yummy Original Fudge topped with sliced bananas topped off with homemade whipped cream and chocolate shavings.

The Mar

$28/$10

Named after our dear friend, this one is the ultimate for the German Chocolate lovers in your life. Adding an amazing layer of coconut, pecans and vanilla, The Mar will have you ready for a second slice.

Sugar Free Original Fudge

$30/$12

Yep, all that chocolate goodness in sugar free. Using Monkfruit and unsweetened chocolate, gives this pie a richness that’s not to miss.

Variety Pie Box

$38

Introducing our Variety Pie Box where you can pick four different flavors of Just Enough sizes to take to your next dinner party and share between friends and family. Choose from: Original Fudge, Peanut Butter Fudge, Kentucky Bourbon Pecan, Schmoo S’mores or The Mar.

Keep checking back for new flavors and let us know if there’s one you want and we’ll try to make it for you.