Frequently Asked Questions

Please reach us at info@schmoo-pies.com if you cannot find an answer to your question.

So excited to have gotten a SchmooPie! Do I need to refrigerate it?

Our fudge pies can last up to a week on the counter or in the fridge without needing to be frozen. We can't guarantee they won't be eaten though.

Our other pies, including Chess and Pumpkin, should be refrigerated and will last up to three days or should be frozen.

Will your pies freeze well?

Yes! Our pies freeze beautifully. For our whole pies, we recommend placing them in the freezer overnight as you receive them. Then once frozen, remove them and wrap them with foil or plastic wrap to preserve the yummy flavor. They'll last for up to 3 months this way. When you're ready to enjoy them, simply place them in the fridge overnight or Fudge based pies can sit on counter. No need to reheat. Enjoy!

How about the Mini Me's freezing?

Yep, them too! For those, we recommend simply placing them directly into a sealable bag and placing them in the freezer.

I don't see my favorite pie flavor, do you bake others?

Please let us know what your favorite pies are and yes, we'd love to try and bake them! Right now, we offer flavors that we can share with you that will be of the best quality given our current space.